Thinking Nutrition

For the latest nutrition research and controversies

  • Home
  • About
  • Articles
    • Cancer
    • Diabetes
    • Gut Health
    • Mental Health
    • Women’s Health
    • Child Health
    • Heart Health
    • Eating Well
    • Managing Weight
    • Nutrition Supplements
    • Getting Active
    • Mythbusting
  • Podcast
  • In the Media
  • Services
  • Privacy
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Eating Well / Are raw food claims overcooked?

Are raw food claims overcooked?

February 19, 2014 by Tim Crowe 4 Comments

Raw foods
Raw Tomato Bread by Irene Mei. CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

Eating only raw foods has emerged as a popular dietary trend. Proclaiming an emotive health message, it is enough to make you think twice before next adding heat to your food. But fear not – on the scales of health, there is little to tip the balance in either direction.

Raw food advocates claim cooking food destroys the natural enzymes and nutrients that would otherwise give us optimal health and control body weight. Following a raw food diet means having almost entirely plant-based foods including fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, grains, vegetable oils and juices in their natural uncooked state.

On the pro side, there is great merit in a raw foods diet. If you are currently eating a lot of processed food, then switching to raw foods will be a clear nutritional win. Where the science gets murky is claims that raw foods are better because cooking destroys enzymes in plants. It’s 100 percent correct that cooking will do this. But so too does digestion. Few enzymes survive their trip through a hydrochloric acid spa bath in the stomach.

Where there is small kernel of truth to raw food claims is the nutrient loses from cooking. Yet this is a clear case of be alert, not alarmed. The United States Department of Agriculture has compiled a detailed table of nutrient losses for 16 vitamins and eight minerals from 290 foods using a variety of cooking methods. For anyone overtly fixated on just what proportion of nutrients they are losing when they cook food, this is the best resource you will find.

A quick glance at the table shows that most minerals are unaffected. Only vitamin C, folate and thiamin stand out as being the main nutrients lost, but even then, levels rarely drop to 50%.

raw foods
Garden Harvest by Dave Gunn. CC BY-NC 2.0

Losing vitamin C, thiamin and folate from cooking vegetables is easily offset by eating foods that are high in these nutrients and are not normally cooked further.

Citrus fruits are an excellent source of vitamin C. Leafy green vegetables and avocados are high sources of folate, as is bread (which is fortified with folic acid). Vegemite is packed with thiamin and because of fortification, so too is bread.

Putting nutrient losses from cooking into context, just storing fruits and vegetables for several days means a gradual loss of vitamin C. Fresh will always be best, but frozen vegetables are certainly an option to consider as they are blanched and frozen very soon after picking, effectively “locking in” their nutrients for months.

Food though is much more than just the essential vitamins and minerals. There are hundreds of bioactive compounds found in plant foods that have favourable health benefits. They can serve as antioxidant and anti-inflammatory agents and have anti-cancer and antibacterial roles as well.

Cooking losses of these bioactive nutrients is considered small; in many cases, cooking can actually increase the amount of some of these substances. Heating food breaks down plant cell walls so they can release more of their nutrients.

Numerous studies have shown that the beneficial antioxidant, lycopene, for example, is much higher in cooked tomatoes than in uncooked tomatoes. Adding a bit of olive oil increases absorption even more. The Mediterraneans were certainly on to something.

So how do you ensure the highest retention of nutrients during cooking? The three keys are water, temperature and time. As temperature, cooking time, and water volume go up, so too do nutrient losses. If you can, steam rather than boil as this cuts down on nutrient leaching. Cook at lower temperatures where possible, or use a higher temperature for a shorter time.

Vegetables
Public Domain Image

Keep the size of vegetable pieces as large as possible to minimise oxidation losses. And don’t overcook food: you want your broccoli firm and green, not wilted and white. Choosing an exclusively raw-food diet can potentially put a person at a small disadvantage. When you exclude all cooked foods, you also exclude many healthy foods, and the nutrient diversity of your diet narrows.

Take the nutrient powerhouses beans and lentils. When cooked, they are a cornerstone to super-healthy vegetarian, Japanese and Mediterranean diets. Legume-based diets have many health benefits including the prevention and management of obesity, heart disease and stroke, diabetes and metabolic syndrome.

Cooking can also destroy some of the anti-nutrients found in foods that bind minerals in the gut and interfere with absorption.

And the elephant in the room when it comes to cooking is not what it adds, but what it takes away. Cooking food at 75°C or hotter will kill most bacteria that causes food poisoning.

Unquestionably, there are many benefits to eating plenty of fruits and vegetables. These foods are high in nutrients and fibre and low in kilojoules. But is raw superior to cooked? A review of 28 research studies found that eaters of both cooked and raw vegetables had a lower risk of cancer compared to people who did not eat many vegetables in the first place.

But the biggest health problems are due to eating too much highly processed, energy-dense, nutrient-poor food. So worrying over losing some vitamin C every time you steam or stir-fry vegetables fades into insignificance when you consider that most in the developed world are not eating enough of these foods in the first place. An emphasis on eating mostly plants is indisputably good, be they raw foods or cooked.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: Eating Well Tagged With: cooked foods, cooking, health, nutrient losses, raw foods, vegetables

Comments

  1. Naomi says

    March 24, 2017 at 6:25 pm

    Great article. I tried a predominantly raw diet for a while (more so for interest than anything else) and I tell you, for the fact that you don’t cook the food – there was A LOT of time required for food prep! Feel like some cheese ? Sure I’ll just soak these cashews for six hours, then pop mix it up and into the dehydrator. We’ll have cheese in just a jiffy – give it take 30 hours ! It really wasn’t workable, unless you’re happy to live in salads every day … and when winter clicks over that just doesn’t provide enough warming satisfaction.

    Reply
  2. private blog network 2015 says

    June 10, 2016 at 4:48 am

    Blow Your Competition From The Water With These Browse Engine Optimization Tricks

    A website you develop might look really fancy and pack
    in a great deal of features, but ask yourself a truthful concern here:
    What good are all those whistles and bells doing if nobody’s even visiting your website?
    This is the problem you’re going to have unless you deal with the issue of SEO, so bone up on your skills.

    Increase your website traffic and the income from your site by
    ensuring it has no busted links or pages. Broken links avoid consumers from navigating
    your site. Broken pages are even worse, ever since the material is just missing
    out on. Broken material can’t be indexed by online search engine either, which is also poor marketing.

    Even conserved images and video files on your server can present a chance to enhance in the rankings, so make sure that you’re always
    saving files with keywords. For instance: If you have an image on your site handling
    weight reduction, like a before-and-after picture, ensure you consist of an appropriate
    keyword in the title when you save the image.

    Avoid making use of keywords that are of no significance to your website or product.
    When you do, web crawler bots may mistake your website as spam
    and blacklist your website from the search engine result.
    On the other hand, make certain to include all relevant keywords on your web page as this is the
    page you must desire your customers to see first.

    Be specific about your keywords and phrases and keep it basic.

    If you attempt to capture every keyword in your niche, you will certainly have
    spread yourself too thin. Target a select couple of and use them creatively and
    typically while still keeping a natural flow to your page.
    By doing this you can push to the top of the list a lot easier.

    Efficient SEO techniques will not need a high level of
    skill and even a great deal of effort. Exactly what is essential is that you
    take the right approach. As you find out about SEO,
    you will find that a couple of minor tweaks can relate to huge results.
    Get started on your optimization by utilizing what you have actually discovered
    here.

    For more reference: visit us at SEOBloggerninja

    Reply
  3. Nikki Boswell says

    February 20, 2014 at 12:47 pm

    Great article Tim. The other perspective for a raw food diet is a reduced environmental impact but again I think the key is balance

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. Summer Diet Scorecard | The Dietitian's Pantry says:
    December 8, 2014 at 7:20 pm

    […] is some truth to the claims but as usual they have been blown way out of proportion. Tim’s blog explains in detail about the vitamins and enzymes lost through the cooking and eating of foods. In […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up for updates

Loading
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Recent Posts

  • The weird way that body posture changes taste
  • Collagen supplements: the science behind the health benefits
  • Is adrenal fatigue a thing?
  • Can keto cure cancer?
  • Hypothyroidism and Hashimoto’s disease: what role for diet?

Most Popular Posts

  • Hypothyroidism and Hashimoto’s disease: what role for diet?
  • Broccoli is bad for you, like, really toxic bad
  • Coffee and its surprising health benefits
  • Are collagen supplements legit or just Insta influencer fairy dust?
  • How do the plant-based milks compare?

Get the Book

Understanding NutritionNow in its fourth edition, Understanding Nutrition is the leading text used in nutrition and dietetics courses in Australia and New Zealand. As one of the coauthors, I step you through core topics such as diet planning, macronutrients, vitamins and minerals and follow this with chapters on diet and health, sports nutrition, lifespan nutrition and food safety.

Work with me

If you have a project you would like to discuss be it website or newsletter content, blog or magazine articles, media copy or scientific writing (a career in medical research means I’m pretty handy in writing and reviewing papers and grants) then please get in touch with me.

Back to Top of Page ↑

Creative Commons Licence
All content on Thinking Nutrition by Dr Tim Crowe is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License and can be reused with attribution